You have great taste

photo of a custom cookie decorated in pink pigs

How It Works

  • Step 1: Fill out the inquiry form to request custom cookies. Check out our FAQ below if you have any questions!

  • Step 2: We'll send you an email to finalize the details. Once the invoice is paid, we'll add you to the calendar and start designing your order.

  • Step 3: When it's time, we'll bake and decorate your cookies.

  • Step 4: We'll let you know when your cookies are ready. Enjoy!

Packaging Options

Each cookie is individually heat-sealed in a cellophane bag at no additional cost (right). This helps the cookie to stay fresh for up to two weeks and helps to prevent damage in transportation. Each cookie can also be packaged as a favor and tied with a bow (left) for an additional $0.50 per cookie.

Inquiry Form

FAQs

  • Stevi’s Cookies is a home-based bakery in Warrenton, Virginia and operates in accordance with Virginia Food Laws.

  • Fill out the inquiry form to start an email conversation. If you have not heard back from us within 48 hours, please check your spam folder. Once we finalize the details together, we’ll send you an invoice. We require payment in full before we can reserve your spot on the calendar or begin making your custom order.

  • The earlier the better, but it never hurts to ask. All batches are made to order and require at least 48 hours to complete. We never have “extra cookies laying around.” We’re efficient bakers and we want you to have the freshest cookies possible! Our busiest seasons are May - June and October - December. Please reach out as soon as you can if you’d like cookies during that time.

  • No, that’s what’s so great: your custom cookies are one of a kind. You’re welcome to reference our portfolio for inspiration, but we’ll create a new design together.

  • We will not copy another artist’s work. However, we do encourage you to send us any reference photos or invitations. This helps us get a better idea of the color palette and design elements you’re looking for. From here we can create a cookie set that’s unique, while still incorporating the elements that are important to you.

  • Our signature flavor is vanilla. We also offer chocolate and snickerdoodle upon request.

  • Our kitchen is not certified nut or gluten free. However, we do have family members with nut allergies so the cookies and bakery are nut free. We can bake the recipe with gluten-free ingredients but the equipment is used for both.

  • Custom orders are $60 per dozen with a 1.5 dozen minimum for each theme. We offer a few combinations that include mini cookies, which are $30 per dozen. Pricing is determined by the complexity of the design, size of the cookie, and packaging. Submit an inquiry and we’ll get back to you with a quote.

    Cookies

    • 1.5 dozen regular ($90.00)

    • 1 dozen regular, 2 dozen mini ($120.00)

    • 2 dozen regular ($120.00)

    • 2 dozen regular, 2 dozen mini ($180.00)

    • 3 dozen regular ($180.00)

    • 3 dozen regular, 2 dozen mini ($240.00)

    • 4+ dozen regular ($240.00+)

    Packaging

    • Heat-sealed (included)

    • Favors with ribbon ($0.50/cookie)

  • We use Square for invoicing, which allows you to pay using a credit card, bank account, or Apple Pay.

  • Yes. We are located in Warrenton, Virginia, and offer pickup to specific locations in Haymarket for $5.00. We also offer delivery to your home or other specified locations for a fee based on time/distance. Orders over $600 are eligible for free delivery.

  • Yes. Our cookies freeze very well and can last up to three months. Each order comes with instructions for the best way to freeze.

  • We offer refunds if you cancel your order 7 business days prior to your pick-up date. No refunds will be given for cookies that have already been made, as our orders are custom and perishable.